Hamza Shailia,
Tae Kyong John Kimb and
Clemens Burda*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, USA. E-mail: burda@case.edu
bSwagelok Center for Surface Analysis of Materials, School of Engineering, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, USA
First published on 18th June 2025
Achieving highly fluorescent and stable perovskite materials has remained a significant challenge in recent years. While several works have reported high photoluminescence and moderate stability in various perovskite systems, this study reports for the first time a photoluminescence quantum yield of 100% with exceptional stability through lanthanide doping of the Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 double perovskite. The lanthanide doping process resulted in a strong and efficient broadband self-trapped exciton (STE) emission. Remarkably, the Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6, and Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample exhibited a warm-white light emission with near-unity PLQY of 99.8% and 100%, respectively, while the pristine sample delivered a 2.3% PLQY only. Structural characterization confirmed the high purity of the samples with near-stoichiometric composition of the materials, with no detectable evidence for secondary phases. The samples maintained their superior emission properties over extended periods of testing. When assembled into a white-light-emitting diode (WLED), the materials generated a strong broadband luminescence (EL) with an excellent color rendering index (CRI) of 91.3 and a correlated color temperature (CCT) of 2826 K, achieving a highly efficient and stable performance. This study highlights that lead-free double perovskites can be reliable and highly efficient materials for commercial LED devices, paving the way for a more sustainable and efficient lighting solution.
New conceptsAttaining highly fluorescent and stable perovskites has been challenging withing recent years due to several factors. Many groups have reported an increase in these properties of perovskite particularly in double perovskites. However, the results are still not at the level of expectations for these materials to be considered as a reliable material for industrial applications. In this study, full unity photoluminescence has been proven to be achievable in double perovskite materials by engineering their properties using several dopants. For the first time, we were able to achieve full unity photoluminescence in double perovskite samples. The prepared samples showed a warm-white light emission with superior PLQY having 100% for Yb3+ doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6, and 99.8% for Er3+ doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample. Structural characterization emphasized the purity of the samples with stoichiometric composition and no second phases detected. We have found that the prepared samples were super stable and maintained most of its emission after running several stability tests and measurements. The assembled WLED generated a strong broadband electroluminescent (EL) with excellent properties. Our findings further emphasize the fact that double perovskites can be reliable materials for commercial LED applications. |
To address these issues, lead-free double perovskites have gained significant attention as ideal alternatives for light-emitting applications. They offer tunable properties to generate superior luminescence through doping engineering, exceptional stability in diverse environments, and environmental compatibility.13–15 Double perovskites (DPs), characterized by the general formula Cs2A+B3+X6 (A+ = Ag+, Na+, Cu+, and K+; B3+ = Bi3+, Sb3+, and In3+; X = Cl−, Br−, and I−), exhibit versatile properties depending on their composition, making them suitable for potentially many applications.16–18 Despite their potential, however, most pristine DPs suffer from low photoluminescence quantum yields (PLQYs) owing to their indirect bandgap characteristics.19,20
Lanthanide doping has proven to be a powerful strategy to tailor the optical properties of solid-state materials, particularly perovskites. Multiple reports have shown that doping can significantly enhance the luminescence of double perovskite, especially using rare earth elements. The sensitization of self-trapped excitons (STEs) can result in strong visible-light emission alongside near-infrared (NIR) emissions.21–23 Notable examples include an 82.5% PLQY reported by Tran et al. for Yb3+-doped Cs2AgBiBr6 with excellent stability,24 Zhou et al. reported strong white photoluminescence generated from STEs using Sb3+/Bi3+-codoped Cs2NaInCl6 with a 77% PLQY,25 and Zhen et al. were able to achieve a white emission with 75.89% PLQY using Sb3+-doped Cs2NaInCl6 double perovskite.26 Furthermore, Saikia et al. achieved a blue and short-wave infrared (SWIR) emission from Sb3+–Er3+-codoped Cs2NaInCl6 showing an impressive 93% PLQY,27 marking the highest internal emission quantum yield achieved for doped double perovskites to date.
In this study, we present a breakthrough in the synthesis of highly fluorescent doped-Cs2NaInCl6 microcrystals with warm white emission. Using a simple precipitation method, we successfully synthesized Ag+, Bi3+, and lanthanide (Ln3+ = Yb3+, Er3+) tri-doped Cs2NaInCl6 microcrystals, achieving unity photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) for the first time. Specifically, the Yb3+-doped sample exhibited a 100% PLQY, while the Er3+-doped sample reached 99.8% PLQY. These samples displayed strong broadband emissions driven by self-trapped excitons (STEs), with warm white-light and NIR emissions at ∼990 nm for Yb3+ and ∼1540 nm for Er3+. Most remarkably, the samples retained 98% of their PLQY over 60 days, confirming their exceptional stability. To demonstrate the practical application of these materials, we assembled a white light-emitting diode (WLED) by coupling the powder samples with a UV LED chip, generating warm white emission with high efficiency. Our findings propose tri-doped Cs2NaInCl6 microcrystals as transformative materials for next-generation light-emitting applications, addressing the challenges of sustainability and efficiency for future LED lighting technologies.
To investigate the size, morphology of the crystals, and elemental distribution, we performed scanning electron microscopy (SEM) alongside X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) analysis. Fig. 1c presents SEM micrographs of the Yb3+- and Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 microcrystals. For the Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample, highly crystalline microcubes with varying sizes were observed suggesting high crystallinity and quality of the prepared microcrystals. In contrast, the Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6, exhibited dissimilar shapes and sizes, indicating a different crystallization behavior. EDS analysis was conducted to quantify the stoichiometry of the samples. The data in Table S1 and S2 (ESI†) illustrate the stochiometric nature of the prepared sample by having a near-perfect balance of the main elements and dopant content in the samples.
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis of the samples is shown in Fig. S2 and S3 (ESI†). The XPS data reveal the presence of the main elements (Na, Cs, In, and Cl) alongside the dopants (Ag, Er, and Yb). The dopant peaks were assigned by their specific binding energies of 366, 168, and 183 eV corresponding to Ag 3d, Er 4d, and Yb 3d, suggesting the successful insertion of dopant ions into the Cs2NaInCl6 host lattice. Although the bismuth peak was detected, it overlapped with a cesium peak. Quantitative elemental analysis using Multipack software aligns well with our EDS results, reaffirming the near-stoichiometric nature of the prepared samples. To assess luminescence properties, the 5%Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 microcrystals were dispersed in DMSO and drop-cast onto a glass substrate as illustrated in Fig. 1e. When exposed to a 365 nm UV lamp, the coated sample exhibited intense warm white light emission, highlighting its strong photoluminescence.
Further vibrational analysis of lanthanide-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 microcrystals was conducted to inspect the purity of the sample and the effect of dopant insertion on the crystal structure and vibrational properties. The Raman spectra of the samples are displayed in Fig. 1f, where two distinct peaks at 145 and 295 cm−1 are attributed to the A1g and 2A1g vibrational modes of the octahedral structure. The differences in peak intensities and broadening observed are indicative of lattice strain generated by dopant incorporation. This strain primarily impacts the stretching vibrations of the octahedra, leading to the observed broadening of the Raman peaks.32
To explore the doping effect on the optical properties, UV-vis diffuse reflectance and steady-state photoluminescence (PL) measurements were performed. The diffuse reflectance spectra in Fig. 2a illustrate an increasing reflectance of the microcrystals as doping increases, starting from 400 nm and reaching high reflectance percentages in the 550–900 nm range in good agreement with the emission and PLQY data. The 5%Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 exhibited the highest reflectance around the absorption edge (∼340 nm) and decreased to around 30% at 400 nm and spiked further to nearly 100% in the visible range. The same trend was observed for the other samples with relatively different intensities ranging from 75 to 95%.
Photoluminescence measurements were carried out across a range of excitation wavelengths (300–350 nm) and the most intense emission was recorded at 332 nm. The pristine material showed a weak emission in the visible range (450–670 nm) as shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†). On the other hand, Fig. 2b and d reveal the PL emission for the various doped samples. Upon lanthanide doping, the Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample exhibited broad emission spanning 425–750 nm, originating from STE recombination driven by Jahn–Teller distortion of [AgCl6]5− octahedra.33 The introduction of silver and bismuth dopants significantly enhances the STE PL intensity producing an outstanding emission yield as the dopant concentration increased. With Bi3+ (5%) and Ag+ (10%) concentrations fixed, varying amounts of Yb3+ and Er3+ doping were introduced leading to a significant increase in the emission and STE activity. These self-trapped excitons (STEs) are excitons (bound electron–hole pairs) that localize in the material due to strong interactions with the lattice itself. In materials with soft lattices and strong electron–phonon coupling, such as halide double perovskites (in our case: doped Cs2NaInCl6), the presence of an exciton can locally distort the crystal structure. This distortion creates a potential well that effectively “traps” the exciton in place, even in the absence of any defects or impurities. Because the trapping is self-induced and does not rely on additional factors like lattice imperfections, it is often referred to as “self-trapping”. In addition, the samples maintained the same broadband emission spectra spanning the entire 425–750 nm visible-light range with stronger emission attributed to enhanced STEs as a result of the localized states below the conduction band minimum created by dopant, particularly by lanthanide incorporation. No distinguished peak corresponding to any specific transition was detected individually as the emission was strong and broad enough to cover the entire range. When the lanthanide doping exceeded 5%, a decrease in the intensity of the emission was noticed as evidenced by a weaker emission at 10% of Yb3+ or Er3+ content.
The lanthanide doping not only improves the visible-range emission properties but also triggers NIR emission into the host materials owing to the newly introduced energy levels within the material. NIR emission was detected when the samples were excited at higher intensity, as shown in Fig. 2c. The NIR emission is strong evidence that the lanthanides were successfully incorporated within the Cs2NaInCl6 crystal structure, as supported by XPS data. Unlike the broadband visible emission, the NIR emission intensity increased with higher lanthanide doping. The observed NIR emission for Yb3+ primarily originates from the 2F5/2 → 2F7/2 transition, while the Er3+-induced emission is assigned to 4I9/2 → 4I15/2, 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transitions in the visible range. The IR transition 4I13/2 → 4I15/2 from Er3+ was beyond the detection limit of our instrument. This energy transfer process is illustrated in Fig. 2e. To further elucidate energy transfer mechanisms, the streak image of 5%Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 was recorded and is shown in Fig. 2f. The profile reveals excellent agreement between the steady-state emission spectrum and time-resolved emission behavior, characterized by intense, broad emission exhibiting a gradual decay. This confirms efficient energy transfer within the doped material, highlighting its potential for high-performance optical applications.
Time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) measurements were carried out on the different DPs prepared with varying dopant concentrations to investigate their fluorescence decay behavior. The PL decay curves of Yb3+- and Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 were measured upon excitation at 332 nm and are shown in Fig. 3a and b, respectively. The TRPL decay curves were fitted using tri-exponential functions, reflecting multiple relaxation dynamics within the samples. The pristine Cs2NaInCl6 sample showed very short lifetime carriers which are consistent with our previous findings and indicated by the very low PLQY.36 The Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample PL decay curves showed two components having a short-lived component (τ1 = 274.81 ns) and a longer-lived component was also found (τ2 = 1490.21 ns) as shown in Fig. S3 (ESI†). For 5%Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6, the PL decay curves exhibited a shorter-lived component (τ1 = 85.59 ns), which might be generated as the result of energy transfer or shallow trap states. Furthermore, two longer-lived components were observed (τ2 = 581.85 ns, τ3 = 2076.42 ns) corresponding to the spin-triplet excited-state transitions introduced by the dopant ions.34 However, due to the broad emission, the individual transitions could not be distinctly resolved. Similarly, for the 5%Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample, the PL decay curve included a shorter-lived component (τ1 = 78.89 ns) and two longer-lived components (τ2 = 603.71 ns, τ3 = 1909.46 ns). The average lifetime of the Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample was 1003.79 ns, and for 5%Yb3+-doped sample was 1290.851 ns, while the average lifetime for the 5%Er3+ sample was 1210.898 ns (Table S5, ESI†). Note that Yb3+ doping generated longer-lived excitons compared to Er3+ ions. The short component is generally related to the nonradiative filling of surface and/or trap states, while the longer lifetime components arise from the slower radiative relaxation process.35 The tri-exponential fluorescence decay observed in these double perovskite samples likely originates from the various relaxation processes within the octahedral structures ([YbCl6]3− or [ErCl6]3−) accompanied by Jahn–Teller-type distortions.23
Photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) was measured at room temperature immediately after the synthesis and every 20 days for the course of 60 days. The undoped Cs2NaInCl6 exhibited a low PLQY of 2.3% which is consistent with the literature value.36 Upon co-doping with Bi3+ and Ag+, the PLQY increased drastically to around 68%, as shown in Fig. 3c and d. After extensive optimization, the ideal dopant concentrations were determined to be 5% for Bi3+ and 10% for Ag+. Upon inducing Yb3+ and Er3+ ions, the PLQY was significantly enhanced and reached a remarkable 99.8% for the 5%Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.5Cl6, and unity PLQY of 100% for 5%Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.5Cl6 (Fig. S4, ESI†). We scanned the PL excitation spectrum over a range of wavelengths and the peak emission was found upon 332 nm excitation, which was then used equally for the steady-state PL and TR-PL measurements. The PLQY values were consistent in all the synthesized batches having values ranging between 100% (highest) and 99.7% (lowest) for Yb3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 samples and 99.8% (highest) to 99.5% (lowest) for the Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 samples as can be shown in Fig. S8 (ESI†) in detail. It is noteworthy that a further increase in doping concentration of lanthanide elements decreased the PLQY. These results demonstrate the critical role of dopant optimization in unlocking the peak emission properties in double perovskites.
To evaluate the phase stability and retention of the PL emission and PLQY of the samples after air exposure, we conducted measurement immediately after the samples were prepared and periodically over the course of 60 days, measuring PL data every 20-days. For the 5%Yb3+-Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample, the PL measurements revealed exceptional stability, retaining 99% of its emission after 20 days and 98% after 60 days. Structural analysis via XRD confirmed high crystal phase stability with no signs of phase deterioration, as shown in Fig. S6 (ESI†). Notably, these results demonstrate superior phase stability under ambient conditions compared to other perovskite materials (Fig. S5, ESI†). The PLQY of the 5%Er3+-Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 sample exhibited minimal degradation over the same period, decreasing slightly to 99% after 20 days and stabilizing at 98.5% after 60 days (Fig. 3f). These findings underscore the excellent environmental robustness of the doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 material, making it a candidate for long-term optoelectronic applications. PLQY data is summarized in Table S6 (ESI†).
To test the suitability of our samples for light-emitting diode (LED) applications, we assembled a white-light emitting diode (WLED) by combining Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6, Yb3+-doped and Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 with a 365 nm UV-LED chip. The luminescence spectrum of the WLED based on Yb3+ and Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6 is shown in Fig. 4b and d, covering nearly the entire visible region of the solar spectrum with a peak emissions at 560 nm and 590 nm, respectively. The Commission Internationale del’Éclairage (CIE) color coordinates of the WLED based on the Yb3+-doped sample were measured as (0.4892, 0.4823). The device achieved a color rendering index (CRI) of 91.3 with a luminous efficiency of 41 lm W−1, and a correlated color temperature (CCT) of 2826 K, aligning well with the standard for warm white lighting (2000–3000 K).37 Similarly, the Er3+-doped Cs2Na0.9Ag0.1In0.95Bi0.05Cl6-based WLED exhibited comparable performance, with CIE coordinates of (0.4931, 0.4743), a CRI of 89.5, a luminous efficiency of 39 lm W−1, and a CCT of 2733 K as shown in Fig. 4e. For stability evaluation, measurements were conducted on two WLED devices: one freshly prepared and another continuously illuminated for 12 hours. The CRI was measured every two hours of operation, showing minimal decrease, as can be seen in Fig. S7 (ESI†). At the same time, the EL emission profiles of both devices were nearly identical, with only a minor variation observed, highlighting the stability and reliability of these materials for practical WLED applications. Furthermore, the samples were placed in 90% humidity and 95 °C temperature for further stability testing. Structural and optical characterization were performed on the sample to analyze its stability. Fig. S10 (ESI†) shows the XRD analysis of the fresh sample compared to the sample placed in high temperature and humidity. The XRD of these samples showed minimal decrease in signal intensity without signs of a phase change. Fig. S9 (ESI†) shows the emission spectrum of the fresh sample compared to the high-humidity/high-temperature sample and the sample immersed in water. The same trend was observed with a minimal decrease in emissions, and no extra emission peaks arose.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5mh00401b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |